Wednesday, October 26, 2011

Copy Edit du Jour

What's more -- aside from a specialized curriculum -- private schools are notoriously known for their smaller classrooms.

Changed to:

Private schools are known for their smaller class sizes.

(Other bad choices aside, I can't BELIEVE the writer used "notoriously known" -- and for something positive, no less. That's the kind of thing I might make up as a ridiculous example of a bad adverb/flabby writing.)

Bookmark and Share


Novice said...


Please forgive my ignorance; what is wrong with "notoriously known?"

June Casagrande said...

"Notorious" and "notoriously" suggest fame, making it somewhat redundant with "known." Also, they usually have a negative implication. (As puts it, notorious means "well known for an undesirable trait or for any particular trait.") And small class size is touted as a good thing.

But, from an editing standpoint, the biggest thing wrong with "notoriously known" is that it can be summed up with just "known." So "notoriously" makes the sentence more wordy while adding nothing of substance.

A common rule of thumb in professional writing and editing is (as Strunk & White are famous for saying) "omit needless words."

Of course, "needless" is always subjective. But in this case, not very.

Hope that helps!

LL Blackwell said...

Dude, that sentence was pretty awesome!

June Casagrande said...

What really gets me is that I write stuff like that, too. Then I look at it an hour later and wonder when and how I ever incurred such serious brain damage.

I guess as long as people keep writing them like that editors will continue to have jobs.


Bookmark and Share